Negros Quake — IT COULD HAVE BEEN WORSE


I know “lucky” is not a word used with a casualty count of 40 — and counting. That figure, from 302nd Brigade chief, Col. Francisco Zosimo Patrimonio Jr. does not yet include La Libertad, another town near the epicenter of today’s Negros Oriental quake.

So far, the hardest hit area is Guihulngan City, a laidback community with the sea on one side and the mountains on the other. But that’s because the quake, which measured 6.9 in Negros Oriental, damaged roads and bridges leading to La Libertad. Patrimonio said only Navy boats can access that town. They weren’t able to send that many rescue teams by later afternoon. As night fell, some Bayan Patrollers were reporting the start of heavy rains there.

It’s bad. There are incessant aftershocks. Phivolcs says these could continue for a week or more. Because big quakes leave the surrounding plates unstable, some aftershocks can be strong.

With La Niña bringing in a cold front — and rain — there will be short-term misery. Unlike incidents of floods, where schools and churches on higher ground open their gates and doors to evacuees, one doesn’t quite know where to go for shelter in Negros Oriental. After all, everybody is scrutinizing homes and buildings for cracks. Aftershocks could also further weaken structures that already sustained earlier damage.

As bad as the situation seems now, however, it could have been worse.

Five beach cottages where swept away by higher-than-usual sea levels in La Libertad. Some coastal homes experienced flooding. But while there was a Tsunami Alert 2, the location of the quake spared the province from greater devastation.

The towns near the epicenter face the narrow Tañon Strait that separates the island from nearby Cebu. It just takes an hour, sometimes less depending on the crossing, to cross that body of water. There isn’t much volume or space for the deadly tsunami build-up. That’s why NDRRMC’s Benito Ramos said what happened was just a minor rise in sea levels — though one preceded by some receding of water, which frightened locals.

Ramos also mentioned Siaton town — which is actually on the other side of Dumaguete City, going towards southern Negros Occidental. Now, had a strong quake occurred off  Siaton or Bayawan and Sta Catalina towns in Negros Oriental, or the most southernmost area on the Occidental side (Hinobaan), the outcome would have been very different.

These areas face the Sulu Sea and there’s a huge empty space between that part of Negros — and Sandakan, in East Malaysia!

The Sulu Sea boasts some of the world’s deepest trenches. which could only allow water to gain more force. Wiki states:

“Tectonic earthquakes are a particular kind of earthquake that are associated with the Earth’s crustal deformation; when these earthquakes occur beneath the sea, the water above the deformed area is displaced from its equilibrium position.[19] More specifically, a tsunami can be generated when thrust faults associated with convergent or destructive plate boundaries move abruptly, resulting in water displacement, owing to the vertical component of movement involved. Movement on normal faults will also cause displacement of the seabed, but the size of the largest of such events is normally too small to give rise to a significant tsunami.”

As the Encyclopædia Britannica points out, the  260,000-sq km sea “fills a downfaulted block, in some places almost 18,400 feet (5,600 meters) deep, the edges of which are seen in the bordering islands.” The lush coral atolls of the Cagayan Islands, the Tubbataha Reefs actually represent “a fracture line that bisects the sea from northeast to southwest”.

Of course, scientists will tell us that not all strong quakes cause deadly tsunamis. There are many factors involve. The National Oceanic & Atmospheric Administration notes:

“Predicting when and where the next tsunami will strike is currently impossible. Once the tsunami is generated, forecasting tsunami arrival and impact is possible through modeling and measurement technologies.” (boldface mine)

MSNBC photo, Aceh tsunami aftermath

There is something about the primal force of water that sends man scurrying more than, say, upheavals on land. (And even on land, as we in this country know too well, the greatest devastation is almost always also connected with water.) In the aftermath of the Aceh quake of December 26, 2004, “tsunami killed about 130,000 people close to the earthquake and about 58,000 people on distant shores. ” The Japan quake last year did not kill people, but the tsunami it generated destroyed a nuclear plant and killed close to 16,000 people.

Nobody, contrary to all those tweets and Facebook posts, can really forecast earthquakes. Humans are lucky, however, that advanced and cost-effective technology is available to allow tsunami alerts. Whether the warning comes fast enough, however, is another story.

Forty dead and counting is bad news from any angle. The cosmic roll of dice, however, could have made for a truly nightmarish situation.

THE STENCH OF NEGLECT, I :Sonny Coloma wrong on Sendong, Pedring & Ondoy


SECRETARY SONNY COLOMA was all over news and social media sites Tuesday, December 27.

Money for new homes for Iligan City residents

There was the Presidential Communications Operations Office chief with Social Welfare Secretary Dinky Soliman and Iligan City Mayor Lawrence Cruz at the turnover of P242 million to rebuild homes washed away by Typhoon Sendong’s floods. (Hurricane Washi)

There he was, in a huddle with Misamis Oriental Gov. Oscar Moreno, discussing rehabilitation plans for Cagayan de Oro and Iligan.  There was even a photo of Coloma in a walkabout of devastated CDO as he led Pilipinas Natin volunteers in relief operations.

The stench of death still wafts over CDO and Iligan and Valencia, in Negros Oriental. Bodies continue to be recovered. The latest eight, believed to be from Iligan, were found in the waters of Sibutad town, Zamboanga del Norte, some 200 kms away from ground zero.

The National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council puts the death count at 1,257. Some organizations place it closer to 1,500.

Tuesday, I barely glanced at those photos and video clips. Now, I can’t help but stare at these and wonder:

As he strolled around these two cities where a thousand died, crushed by debris and churning currents unleashed by Sendong’s torrential rains, did Coloma ponder the role he played in the carnage? A second question also niggles at the mind: Did he even care?

The dead in Iligan City, original file by Bayan Patroller Mark Nambatac

Even as he posed for the cameras, Coloma – one of President Beningo Aquino III’s three communications secretaries – was silent on the failure of a much-heralded disaster mass alert system.

In the immediate aftermath of Sendong, Coloma had been silent, too, except to help excoriate local government officials; this, as charges of neglect and incompetence flew back and forth from ground zero and the Malacanang.

The government has spent the last two weeks insisting it had given ample warning to local government units.

WHO WARNED WHOM?

This report will focus on CDO and Iligan, where most of the contradicting reports on warnings or the lack thereof come from.

As CDO reeled on December 17 from the impact of floods that rampaged just after midnight, Mayor Vicente Emano said they were not warned.

“Wala naman talagang sinabi na ganoon ang mangyayari,” Emano said in an interview with dzMM. “Kami ang tinamaan ng mata ng bagyo, hindi na po sinabi yan.”

“Wala pong nagsabi na ganito ang darating na bagyo sa amin, wala man lang bulletin, wala man lang nakapagsabi na we will be in the eye of the storm,” he added.

National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council (NDRRMC) head Benito Ramos said CDO and Iligan were not prepared because they are not usually visited by strong typhoons.

“Hindi eto damay sa usual na path,” Ramos said. “Ang usual na path n’ya ay Central Visayas. Kung hagip ang Central Mindanao, ang experience ng ating mga kababayan d’yan, ang pinakamataas na ay 60-millimeters ng tubig na madala ng bagyo.”

Ramos has always insisted, however, that neither the NDRRMC nor Pag-asa were remiss in issuing warnings. Let’s work backwards from yesterday.

Late last night, abs-cbnnews.com posted an  admission by Ramos. He echoed an earlier confession by Coloma, that the government failed to use its 1456 emergency alert system to warn CDO and Iligan residents to evacuate.

Coloma issued a statement after telecommunications companies, Smart and Globe, pointed out the government could have saved lives had it used the emergency alert system.

There are two things in Coloma’s statement that struck me:

  • He said the government did not use the alert system in CDO and Iligan cities on December 16 because these areas were under typhoon signal number one and “below the threshold alert level of signal number three.”
  • He said the system works and that government had used it to warn Bulacan residents of floods spawned by Typhoon Pedring in September

TIMELINE

Late last night, Undersecretary Manuel Quezon III, also of the Communications Office of the President but dealing with strategic messaging, forwarded the Timeline of warnings by Pag-asa and the National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council (NDCRRMC). Quezon had promised that timeline on December 18, when he was bring grilled on Twitter over allegations that government had failed to warn CDO and Iligan of incoming floods. Quezon valiantly defended Malacañang, providing a flood of messages to prove that warnings had, indeed, been given. But that’s for the next blog.

Let’s first examine Coloma’s statement. The Pag-asa/NDRRMC Timeline shows this update for 5 am of December 16:

5:00AM: Severe Weather Bulletin No. 4 – 300 km East Southeast of Hinatuan, Surigao del Sur (Signal No. 2 @ Leyte, Camotes, Bohol, Surigao del Norte, Surigao del Sur, Siargao, Dinagat, Agusan, Misamis Oriental, Camiguin, Bukidnon, Davao del Norte, Compostela, Samal, Davao Oriental. Signal No. 1 @ Sorsogon, Ticao, Masbate, Samar, Panay, Guimaras, Negros, Cebu, Siquijor and Biliran, North Cotabato, Northern Davao Del Sur, Lanao Provinces, Misamis Occidental and Zamboanga Provinces)

Mr. Coloma, Cagayan de Oro is the capital of Misamis Oriental. Iligan City technically belongs to Lanao del Norte, but anyone who has visited it knows it is just an hour and a half away from CDO. No, Mr. Coloma, the excuse doesn’t wash.

MAP of CDO and surrounding areas, including Iligan

As for the alert system being used in Bulacan, that province was not under Signal #3 during Typhoon Pedring.  Public Storm Signal No. 3 covered Catanduanes, Camarines Sur, Camarines Norte, Northern Quezon, including Polillo Island, Aurora, Quirino, and Isabela. Bulacan was under Signal #2, with Albay, Burias Island, Sorsogon, rest of Quezon, Rizal, Bulacan, Nueva Ecija, Nueva Vizcaya, Ifugao, Benguet, Mt. Province, Kalinga, and Cagayan.

Again, Coloma’s statement doesn’t stand-up to scrutiny.

It is curious that Coloma makes much of the public storm warning level. A Google search of the MOA between the government and the telco firms digs up a transcript of a briefing Coloma himself presided. Here’s what he said:

“What brought us together in this partnership? You will recall that a few days after the earthquake and tsunami that hit Japan, a hoax text message spread like a virus and created a lot of anxiety regarding possible radiation from the nuclear leak in Fukushima Daiichi Power Plant. Days after the President was nearing the end of his state visit to Singapore, the government issued a tsunami evacuation alert in the aftermath of the 8.9 magnitude earthquake in Japan. In October 2010, PAGASA [Philippine Atmospheric Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration] correctly predicted the coming of super typhoon, Juan, which greatly minimized the number of casualties. We still remember vividly the widespread damage and lost of life brought about by tyhpoons Ondoy and Pepeng in September and October 2009 which caught many citizens unprepared. In response to the challenges posed by the foregoing illustrative events, the major TELCOS [telecommunication companies] have volunteered to support the government through the timely broadcast of text messages—of accurate text messages to their subscribers.”

Mr. Coloma, Metro Manila was under Signal #2 when Ondoy ripped through many of our cities. Do you even do your homework? With so many of our brethren dead, the least you could do is double-check your facts as you defend a grievous sin of omission.

*Next, reviewing Sendong warnings